Blog Layout

February 4, 2024

When Paying Cash Is Cheaper Than Using Insurance

For people with high deductibles, most of their health care spending is out-of-pocket. Health insurance serves as a discount card, yet the discount offers the best price about 50 percent of the time. Sensible Mental Health pioneers a cash-pay alternative, challenging norms and prioritizing affordability and accessible mental health care.

In today's healthcare landscape, a harsh reality persists—many individuals are shouldering the burden of paying for all their care out of pocket. All health-related expenses, throughout the entire year, are often funded directly by the patient. When we consider that 32 percent of Americans have some form of public health insurance, it becomes apparent that the remaining 68 percent are likely to bear the brunt of several thousand dollars in healthcare expenses before insurance contributions kick in. Deductibles, the out-of-pocket amount individuals pay before insurance coverage commences, have steadily risen over the past two decades, rivaling the costs of 1-3 months of housing.


For the 90 percent of Americans who don't reach their deductible, health insurance is more like a discount card.


The evolving nature of healthcare expenses can be challenging to grasp, especially for those who grew up in the era of minimal out-of-pocket costs. The paradigm has shifted, and today, people are confronted with significantly higher out-of-pocket healthcare expenses. Individuals often desire health insurance to cover routine health costs, but it functions more like auto insurance.


Much like we price shop for gas and oil changes, it's time to make asking questions about the cost of healthcare the new norm. Blindly trusting major insurance providers might not always be in your best interest. Studies indicate that negotiated insurance rates are the best price only about half of the time. Surprisingly, paying in cash, whether through HSA, FSA, credit card, check, etc., is often less expensive. Many clinics now offer cash prices at discounted rates, providing an attractive alternative to using insurance.


Practices like Sensible Mental Health are using a unique approach. By pricing their services and passing along administrative savings to clients, they eliminate the administrative burdens associated with insurance. Cash-pay models are gaining traction in psychiatry, primary care, rheumatology, orthopedics, dermatology, and various other specialties, offering cost-effective alternatives for those willing to forego insurance.


Shifting the mindset around seeking healthcare isn’t easy. The ingrained habit of seeking in-network providers and handing over an insurance card at each encounter may not always serve our best interests. Furthermore, long wait times within network providers can drive individuals to explore alternatives. Sensible clients, however, experience a different reality, with new clients securing appointments within a remarkable ten days of their first call.


In this changing landscape, reconsidering how we approach healthcare can lead to not only financial savings but also more immediate and accessible care. Sensible Mental Health stands at the forefront of this shift, prioritizing affordability, efficiency, and client well-being.

Share by: